A Comparative Performance Evaluation of EIGRP in a Mininet/FRRouting-Emulated Network and a Physical Cisco Network

Authors

  • Abdelsalam Melad Faitouri College of Computer Technology, Benghazi Author
  • Najat Faraj Eleshebi College of Computer Technology, Benghazi-Libya Author
  • Mofeda Abdelrrazik Madhi College of Computer Technology, Benghazi Author

Keywords:

EIGRP, Mininet, FRRouting, Convrgence time, QoS

Abstract

Enhanced Interior Gateway Routing Protocol (EIGRP) is typically deployed on dedicated hardware routers, whereas emulation platforms such as Mininet allow routing software to be tested in virtualized environments. In this context, this study investigates the performance of EIGRP in a Mininet/FRRouting emulated network and compares it with an equivalent physical network built with Cisco routers and switches, evaluating network stability and performance. Because FRR support one router per host in this setup, the emulated routers were distributed across four PCs and interconnected through GRE tunnels over a LAN. To achieve this objective, experiments were conducted using the Mininet-based emulation environment. Both networks used the same four-router ring topology and were evaluated under normal operating conditions and link-failure scenarios. The evaluation focused on several key performance metrics, including convergence time, round-trip time (RTT), and quality-of-service (QoS) metrics during RTP/MPEG-2 video streaming between end devices (packet loss, throughput, delay, and jitter). These metrics were used to assess the network's responsiveness to topology changes, data transmission efficiency, and ability to maintain service quality during network failures. The results showed that the emulated environment achieved a convergence time of 2-4 seconds compared with 5-8 seconds in the physical network when a query process was triggered. Furthermore, the emulated environment demonstrated a lower measured RTT of 1.0-1.2 ms, compared with 2.7 ms in the traditional network. During video streaming, the SDN-based environment exhibited a packet loss rate of less than 5%, compared with 35-45% in the physical network during failure, and achieved a throughput of up to 2.5 Mbps, compared with approximately 0.5 Mbps in the physical network. In addition, the emulated environment exhibited more stable delay and jitter performance during link failure. These differences may reflect variations in router implementation, hardware, and link capacity between the two testbeds; the results remain dependent on the experimental architecture and emulation condition and should not be taken as evidence of general superiority of either approach.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-13

Issue

Section

Applied Sciences Theme

How to Cite

Abdelsalam Melad Faitouri, Najat Faraj Eleshebi, & Mofeda Abdelrrazik Madhi. (2026). A Comparative Performance Evaluation of EIGRP in a Mininet/FRRouting-Emulated Network and a Physical Cisco Network . Afro-Asian Journal of Scientific Research (AAJSR), 4(4), 172-178. https://aajsr.com/index.php/aajsr/article/view/1045